Dear Media: Retweets DO Equal Endorsements - Define American

Featured Blog post

Dear Media: Retweets DO Equal Endorsements

Uncritically quoting POTUS tweets in headlines, leads, and videos is an endorsement of administration policy and tactics. Don’t do it.

The president, via social media, is threatening millions of immigrant families with deportation, and media outlets are breathlessly repeating his tweets and anonymous screeds from his deputies as news. This is not how reporting should work.

The Associated Press story at least conveys that the president’s tweets were a threat, not a policy proclamation, and ties the threats to today’s campaign announcement. And CNN acknowledges that the tweets were vague, devoid of details, and countered by some local officials.

Some tips for media outlets covering immigration:

  • Consult the people actually affected.

None of these stories contain reaction from the people actually affected, the millions of immigrant families who are being threatened. When the government threatens a significant portion of the American public, it is incumbent on the media to seek comment and reaction from the people affected.

  • Seek comment from opposition figures.

Only CNN mentions Oakland Mayor Libby Schaaf, but they cite her actions to subvert deportation in her city from a year ago rather than asking her for comment on the latest threats. Multiple candidates for president, immigrant advocacy groups, business, and religious figures all have lots to say about Trump’s anti-immigrant threats. Call them.

  • Avoid anonymous comments, especially when it’s pure speculation or opinion.

The anonymous administration official that several media outlets cite does not add to this story, and this person does not deserve the protection of anonymity. This is pure propaganda.

  • Don’t cite hate groups.

The Center for Immigration Studies has a 34-year track record of trying to end immigration to the U.S. using white nationalist rhetoric, publishing falsified or trumped up research, and working with extremist anti-immigrant politicians. It is neither a think tank nor a “non-profit organization that favors limiting immigration,” as many media outlets dub them. Stop quoting them. And if you are going to quote them, explain their real political aims and their significant ties to the Trump administration.

Let's Talk

Create change, one story at a time.